I’ll go ahead and guess that at this point, you’ve at least heard of Halo Top. If you have no idea what I’m talking about, go check out my original Halo Top review from way back in 2015. Ok, if you’re lazy, I’ll give you a quick run down: Halo Top is a “healthier” ice cream. Each pint has less than 400 calories (most are between 280-360) and they’re lower in sugar, higher in fiber, and higher in protein than most ice creams. Just for comparison, a whole PINT of Halo Top is similar in calories to 1/4 pint of the premium stuff. Does it taste exactly like Ben and Jerry’s? No. Is it delicious? Yes.
Halo Top started out with a pretty traditional line up of flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, & Lemon Cake. Last year, they released a whole line up of new flavors (to read my favorites, check out this post about those Halo Top flavors!) and they’ve come back with an additional 7 flavors (plus one seasonal flavor) so there’s a lot more to try!
To be totally honest, when I heard about the new flavors coming out, I wasn’t really that thrilled about any of them. I’m generally a chocolate fan, and most of the flavors didn’t involve chocolate. But since I get so many questions about Halo Top (and let’s be honest, I love those kinds of questions) I thought I’d do a full review.
Before you go buying some pints, there are a few things to keep in mind:
- Pints of Halo Top aren’t cheap. They’re typically around $5. (Sometimes on sale for $4.) So while the calories might not deter you from eating a whole pint in one sitting, your wallet could.
- They use erythritol and stevia which are low-calorie sweeteners. They’re more “natural” than aspartame, but if you’re wary of those types of sweeteners, you might not want to try these.
- Halo Top has the best texture if you take it out of the freezer for a few minutes before you eat it. It doesn’t have all the stabilizers and softeners that most ice creams contain, so give it a few minutes before you dive in.
- I had a taste testing partner (thanks, Carin!) so I combined our thoughts and feedback below.
- There’s one additional flavor (rainbow swirl) that I haven’t been able to find yet! Once I find it, I’ll add it to the list.
Get those spoons ready. Here we go.
*Seasonal* Pumpkin Pie Halo Top- 360 calories per pint
If you’re a pumpkin fan, you better hurry. This one is a seasonal flavor so it won’t last long! I’ll be honest, I’m not obsessed with pumpkin everything, so this one didn’t grab me. It certainly has a strong pumpkin flavor and it was sweet, creamy, and it had little chunks of pie in it. If you’ve had the Red Velvet Halo Top flavor, it kind of reminded me of that one, but pumpkin flavored. Bottom line, if you love all things pumpkin, I’m pretty certain you’ll enjoy this one!
Mochi Green Tea Halo Top- 320 calories per pint
Of all the new flavors, this one was my least favorite. The green tea flavor was good, but I wasn’t really sure where the mochi part came in. It was a creamy texture and sweet without being overly sweet, but there wasn’t anything about this flavor that had us going back for more.
Cinnamon Roll Halo Top- 360 calories per pint
This one tasted like eating cinnamon roll dough. The cinnamon flavor was quite strong, (maybe a little too strong) but if you’re someone that loves cinnamon rolls, then you should definitely give this one a try. It tasted a bit sweet to me, but the flavor was pretty authentic. It had tiny bits of cinnamon roll pieces, which were a nice addition. You could visually see a cinnamon swirl throughout the ice cream.
Caramel Macchiato Halo Top- 280 calories per pint
Carin and I both agreed that this one tasted like a Starbucks Frappuccino. If you’re someone that loves frappes give this one a try. I’m usually not a big caramel fan but I actually liked that this one had a strong coffee flavor. If you like the sea salt caramel flavor and you’re a coffee fan, I think you’ll like this one.
Pancakes and Waffles Halo Top- 280 calories per pint
This flavor seemed to be all over social media. I had high hopes when I opened it up because I could see the bits of pancake and waffle in the ice cream! Unfortunately, it was way too maple-flavored for my tastes. I’m not a huge maple syrup fan, so I could pass on this, but if you’re someone who truly loves a big stack of hot cakes and syrup, this one’s for you. The texture was great, the pancake bits were tasty, but it heavy on the maple.
Chocolate Covered Banana Halo Top- 280 calories per pint
This one surprised me. I didn’t expect to like it but I found myself going back for more tastes. It definitely has a “banana runts” type of flavor and the banana part is stronger than the chocolate. But as soon as you open the pint, you can see the chocolate swirl in there and the flavor comes through nicely. If you don’t like banana flavored things then you should pass on this one (I mean, obviously) but if you’re on the fence, you might be pleasantly surprised. Carin ranked this one as her #1 of the new Halo Top flavors, and it was my #2 pick.
Candy Bar Halo Top- 360 calories per pint
I came in with high hopes for this one and I wasn’t disappointed. This one was the most chocolatey of the new flavors and it had lots of candy pieces. We felt like the “candy bar” this pint was supposed to resemble was probably a Snickers. (The peanut pieces led us down that path.) To me, this one tasted the most like “regular” ice cream, thanks to all the mix ins. This was my #1 pick and Carin’s #2 pick.
So how do these compare to all the other Halo Top flavors?
I’d say peanut butter cup is still my overall favorite. Those peanut butter swirls are down right heavenly. But if you’re just not a peanut butter fan (who are you?!) then Candy Bar would be my next pick! It’s a tight race for third place, but I’d probably go with cookie dough or chocolate, depending on my mood!
Overall, I think the flavors are on point. If you’re crazy for pumpkin, you’ll probably like pumpkin. If you’re obsessed with cinnamon, get yourself a pint of the cinnamon roll! Carin and I were both impressed at how so many of the flavors were truly on point. I know Halo Top isn’t everyone’s cup of tea (or pint of ice cream?) but if you’re curious about the new flavors, give them a try!
Just FYI- this post isn’t sponsored at all. I’m not, nor have I ever been, compensated by Halo Top. As always, these are my honest opinions!