Vegan Buckeyes!

Apparently my sweet tooth has been controlling my brain lately, because it seems like I’ve been overdosing on sweets. Yesterday, in support of Ohio State, I decided to whip up some buckeye candies! (Sadly, we lost… but the candy was still delicious!)

So what is a buckeye, you ask?

Buckeye– a kind of tree… the nut of which, looks like a “buck’s eye”…

Thinking about the eye of a deer is kind of gross. Moving on.

Luckily, the candy kind are DELICIOUS! Maybe you’ve had them before. (Maybe you have awesome friends like Katie, who aren’t from Ohio, but made them for her Ohio friend!) But lots of people here in VA haven’t tried them before! Thankfully, people from any state can agree that PB + Chocolate was a match made in heaven.

These are pretty simple to make, but there are a few tricks for success!

Vegan Buckeyes

  • 1 cup butter/margarine (I used earth balance light)
  • 1 1/2 cups creamy peanut butter
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • 6 cups powdered sugar
  • 2 cups chocolate chips

Soften the butter, but don’t melt it. Whip it with the peanut butter and then add the butter. Once that is combined, slowly stir in your powdered sugar. I always get impatient and get powdered sugar all over myself and the counter. This isn’t a required step, but it seems to be for me…

Once that’s combined, roll into little balls. Stick a toothpick in each of the balls

Freeze for ~30min or longer

Melt your chocolate chips in a little dish. I recommend a ramekin dish! Microwave for 30 seconds at a time and stir, stir, stir so it doesn’t burn!

Take the pb balls out of the fridge and dip into the chocolate, leaving a little bit exposed, so it looks like a buckeye! You might need to stick the pb balls back into the freezer as you dip, because if you let them get too soft, they slide off the toothpick…

Not good! 🙁 Make sure you keep them cold enough for dipping!! Once they’re dipped, pop the finished product in the freezer for a bit, and then store in the fridge.

As if that wasn’t enough sweetness. I took my first trip to SweetFrog, the new fro-yo place near by!

My friend Nicole and I loaded up our bowls with deliciousness.

Mine was chocolate + peanut butter + espresso ice cream, topped with strawberries, graham crackers, and pretzels.

It was AMAZING. This place is going to be a summer staple. I can tell.

Have you ever had buckeyes? Do you make something similar, but call them something else?

What’s your favorite fro-yo topping?

Hope you’re all having a fantastic weekend!

<3 Liz


  1. Aww hehe yay for buckeyes! Yay for anything chocolate, really… except chocolate bacon ;).

  2. oh my gosh i totally thought you were going to cook with those! we call them Conkers over here! or maybe thats just the game… hmm
    anywho i LOVE this recipe!

  3. YUmmmmy So awesome! thank you for stopping by my blog. Hugs, Anne

  4. I’ve never had Buckeyes but they look so delicious.
    Yum! Frozen yogurt is so good. My fave topping is coconut

  5. I’ve never had buckeyes before but anything with chocolate is a win for me. Loving the pretzels on your fro-yo. I love mine with sprinkles, oreos, strawberries, and peanut butter cups. 😀

  6. Now those look a lot better then the name implies! Can’t wait to make them. I love cookie dough topping on my yogurt

  7. Gasp. How is it possible that I have gone through life so far never having heard of buckeyes? Peanut butter. And chocolate. It’s all so beautiful. *sob*

  8. I’ve never heard of buckeyes- how is that possible?! My dad’s side of the family is from Ohio! Geez, all this time they knew about a peanut butter and chocolate dessert and they didn’t tell me!!

  9. I’ve never heard of buckeyes before! They sound so delicious though! Sorry Ohio State lost! That totally ruined my boyfriend’s bracket!

  10. Awww… those buckeyes are SO, SO cute!!!! 😀
    And it’s kind of funny, I just had fro-yo last night! Mmmmm…. 🙂

  11. Awwwwwwwe, those buckeyes are the cutest things EVER! 😀


  12. Those look super fabulous! And I love froyo with LOTS of fruit on top! 🙂

  13. Oh my gosh, peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate? YUM

    love love love froyo!

  14. The buckeyes came out great! I didn’t realize that’s why they were called that…. yikes! I’ll block that one from my brain and move on to that delish froyo! <3

  15. Book-marking this! You just made my day!

    Chocolate + PB = LOVE.


  16. Aw you call them buckeyes in america! We call them conkers in the UK hehe so weird! That fro-yo place looks amazing, another thing that we dont really have in the UK 🙁 so jealous, the one you got looks delicious.

  17. As my wedding favor we made over 400 buckeyes! IT was a trip but in the end they turned out great!!

  18. yummy yyummy I love buckeyes!

  19. I’m from Ohio too – and I love Buckeyes! I haven’t had them in so long though. My favorite fro yo toppings are chocolate and pomegranate seeds.

  20. That’s a great idea about the yogurt! I’ll have to try it! Thanks 🙂

    I just bought a sweet potato and some asparagus at the grocery store but haven’t made it yet… your food looks delish!

  21. Hell to the yes with the pretzels on the froyo!


  1. […] excited. As I made the brownies, I started brainstorming different frosting recipes. I think the vegan buckeyes were still on my mind, because I settled on a peanut butter […]

  2. […] Covered Goodies aka Buckeyes. These were basically all butter and sugar and way too rich. I’ve made these vegan before but […]

Speak Your Mind